Cheapest tillage pass is the one you don't make

FPWF - Fri Oct 16, 2:00AM CDT

by Mark Licht, Eric Weuve and Richard M. Cruse

Harvest is underway across Iowa, and one of the biggest surprises this season may not be on the yield monitor. 

It’s at the fuel pump. 

Diesel prices have increased sharply ahead of the 2026 harvest season, substantially increasing operating costs and making every tillage pass more expensive than budgeted for last winter. 

With fuel costs high and margins tight, this fall may be a good time to reevaluate whether every tillage pass is necessary. For many Iowa corn-soybean rotations, reduced-tillage systems such as no-till soybean or strip-till corn can lower fuel expenses without sacrificing productivity.

Each tillage pass carries direct costs through fuel consumption, labor, machinery wear and depreciation. Iowa State University's Ag Decision Maker cost of production identifies fuel, repairs and machinery ownership costs as significant components of crop production expenses. 

Reducing field operations is one of the few immediate opportunities to lower production costs with no or only minimal effect on seed, fertilizer or chemical costs.

Proven way to reduce expenses

While tillage has long been viewed as a standard fall practice for some farmers in parts of Iowa, current fuel prices provide a strong reason to question whether the benefits of each pass justify the expense. 

Soybean acres following corn are often excellent candidates for no-till or reduced-till systems. Research from Iowa State University has consistently shown that soybean fields are highly adaptable to reduced-till and no-till systems, with little or no yield penalty in many environments when stands are established successfully. 

Making sure the planter is properly set up to get the desired planting depth and furrow closure is the most important step to ensuring adequate soybean emergence and plant populations.

Beyond fuel savings, reducing or eliminating fall tillage can improve operational efficiency by allowing more acres to be covered in less time during the often-short window between harvest and winter.

Don't ignore compaction 

Fuel savings should not be the only factor influencing tillage decisions this fall. Harvest conditions matter. If combines, grain carts and trucks are operating on wet soils, compaction risk increases significantly.

Before scheduling tillage, assess whether actual compaction problems exist. Deep ruts and severe compaction zones may require corrective action. 

However, rut repair and compaction management are not always the same thing. Shallow surface ruts can often be addressed with minimal soil disturbance, while severe subsurface compaction may require a more targeted and aggressive approach.

Tillage conducted under wet soil conditions causes smearing and structural damage while consuming expensive fuel. With water-logged soils in much of Iowa this fall, deep tillage will have little or no positive effect on compaction problems, and may even make problems worse. 

In many fields, especially those harvested under favorable conditions, leaving residue undisturbed ahead of soybean planting may be the more economical and agronomically sound decision.

As harvest continues, take a fresh look at your tillage plans. High fuel prices make every field pass more expensive than it was just a few months ago. For many, one of the easiest ways to reduce machinery costs this fall may be to eliminate tillage for next year’s soybean crop. 

When fuel prices rise, the cheapest tillage pass is often the one you don’t make.

A look at examples 

Variable cost savings from three examples are shown in the following table. It is assumed that savings would be in equipment variable costs, with no changes to the equipment lineup, and the current planter setup is capable of no-till soybean planting.  

Simply eliminating unnecessary tillage can result in significant direct savings without considering soil compaction that tillage itself may cause under wet conditions this fall, as we have in much of Iowa.

chart

Licht is a cropping systems specialist at Iowa State University Extension and Outreach and co-director of the Iowa Soybean Research Center. Weuve is a farm management specialist for ISU Extension. Cruse is an ISU agronomy professor and director of the Iowa Water Center.